+
Progressive Insurance in Alabama
TCDS is an authorized Progressive agent. But here's what most agents won't tell you: Progressive isn't always the cheapest option—even though their ads say they are.
The Honest Truth About Progressive
What Progressive Won't Tell You
Progressive's "Name Your Price" tool and comparison shopping ads are brilliant marketing. But here's the reality: Progressive only compares you to a handful of carriers, and they profit most when you choose Progressive.
As an independent agent, we have zero incentive to push one carrier over another. We get paid the same commission regardless of which carrier you choose. Our job is to find you the actual best rate—not just the best Progressive rate.
When Progressive IS the Best Choice
- Younger drivers (under 25): Progressive often beats competitors for this age group
- High-risk drivers: Recent accidents or tickets? Progressive's non-standard division is competitive
- Bundling multiple vehicles: Their multi-car discount is solid (up to 20%)
- Snapshot usage-based program: Safe drivers can save 10-30% with their telematics device
When Progressive Usually ISN'T the Best Choice
- Drivers over 50: Carriers like Nationwide and Safeco often beat Progressive by $200-400/year
- Homeowners bundling: Progressive's home insurance (underwritten by others) is rarely the cheapest
- Clean driving record 5+ years: You're paying for Progressive's brand, not getting the best rate
- Rural Alabama: Regional carriers often beat Progressive by 15-25% outside metro areas
Real Alabama Data: Progressive vs. Competition
Based on 500+ quotes we ran in 2024 for Alabama drivers:
Average Progressive Auto Quote: $1,847/year
Birmingham metro area, 35-year-old driver, clean record
Average Best Competing Quote: $1,423/year
Savings of $424/year (23% less than Progressive)
Progressive Was Cheapest: 31% of the time
Another carrier beat Progressive 69% of the time
What You Get With Progressive Through TCDS
Progressive Coverages Available:
- • Auto Insurance (standard & non-standard)
- • Motorcycle Insurance
- • RV & Motorhome Insurance
- • Boat & Watercraft Insurance
- • Homeowners Insurance (underwritten by ASI)
- • Renters Insurance
- • Condo Insurance
- • Commercial Auto Insurance
- • Business Owners Policy (BOP)
Progressive Discounts:
- • Multi-car discount (up to 20%)
- • Multi-policy discount (home + auto)
- • Snapshot usage-based discount (up to 30%)
- • Continuous insurance discount
- • Homeowner discount (even if home insured elsewhere)
- • Pay-in-full discount
- • Paperless discount
- • Good student discount (under 25)
Why Get Progressive Through TCDS Instead of Direct?
Same Price, Better Service
You pay the exact same premium whether you buy direct or through us. But with TCDS, you get a local agent who answers the phone.
We Compare 50+ Carriers (Not Just 4-5)
Progressive's comparison tool only checks a handful of carriers. We check 50+, including regional carriers Progressive doesn't show you.
Claims Advocacy
When you have a claim, we work with Progressive on your behalf. Direct customers navigate claims alone.
Easy Carrier Switching
If Progressive raises your rates next year, we can instantly shop you to 49 other carriers. Direct customers have to start over.
Let's Find Out If Progressive Is Really Your Best Option
Get a real Progressive quote plus quotes from 49 other carriers. Takes 5 minutes. Zero obligation.